In the world of logistics, no two days are the same. A business could be managing big-box home deliveries or running a wholesale distribution network, either way the demands placed on its operation are constantly shifting. A customer’s expectations may have changed, a driver may no longer be available, there’s congestion on a route like the M25, products could have different handling requirements, or unexpected operational challenges might have occurred.
Any one of these unpredictable events occurring could quickly disrupt even the most prepared business. This is why effective logistics planning cannot simply be about finding the most efficient route from A to B. It has to begin with considering the outcome the customer actually expects.
James Redfearn, Vice President of Fleet Solutions in EMEA at Descartes, believes there are generally four types of customer expectations: somebody who wants a delivery cheaply, somebody who wants it fast, somebody who wants it conveniently and somebody who wants it eco-friendly. The challenge for logistics operators is that delivering against each of these expectations can require a very different approach to planning and execution. All this alongside managing their own operational requirements.
The shortest route isn’t always the best route
When planning routes, operators need to start by defining the outcome they want to achieve, rather than automatically looking for the shortest distance between two points. This is because a route designed to minimise cost may look very different, for example, from one designed around being faster.
It’s often assumed that taking the shortest route is the quickest and most economical, but that isn’t always the case. Take businesses using the M25 as an example. For operators working around London, the M25 may appear to provide the shortest route between certain locations. But congestion, accidents and the time of day can significantly change the outcome. In some circumstances, taking a longer alternative route may make more sense from both a journey-time and emissions perspective.
The same principle applies across different operating environments. A vehicle running into central London has a completely different route profile to one operating in the villages of Oxfordshire. Congestion, stopping, idling, braking, driver hours and shifts all influence the actual cost and efficiency of a journey. Distance therefore can’t be the only measure used to determine whether a route is efficient.
Plan for the outcome the business needs
Rather than planning against a single objective, operators need to consider multiple constraints together. That means looking at cost, profit, delivery windows, vehicle capacity, emissions, and customer requirements as part of the same decision-making process. Customer satisfaction also needs to be part of that equation. A route may appear efficient overall, but individual deliveries within it may still be expensive or poorly matched to the vehicle being used. Scenario modelling gives businesses the ability to understand these trade-offs before decisions are made. Instead of simply asking which route is shortest, operators can test which option best delivers the outcome required.
Sending a vehicle from a regional distribution centre (RDC) in Leeds to make a single delivery in Aberdeen may complete the order, but it is unlikely to represent the most efficient use of the network. Businesses need the logic and data to understand those trade-offs before the decision is made. The question is therefore no longer simply whether a route is the shortest.
Use capacity more intelligently
Once operators start planning around outcomes, several areas of inefficiency become easier to identify. Delivery slots are one example. Say a customer might be able to have a product delivered during one time window for £20. But if the business is already delivering in that area during another time window, perhaps that delivery can be offered for £1. That makes logical sense to the customer while allowing the operator to use capacity that already exists.
- Every key deadline: diesel rebate, fuel excise, carbon tax
- Tick-box checklist for tacho, CVRT, CPC & operator licence
- Where drivers get caught at RSA roadside checks
By understanding the product, available capacity and service time associated with each delivery, operators can assess which vehicles can fulfil an order and what adding it will mean for the wider route. As new orders are placed, those options can be readjusted. The same approach applies to vehicle utilisation. Most fleet operators have seen large vehicles understocked when leaving the yard. There can be a significant mismatch between fill capacity, vehicle utilisation and the actual cost of that delivery.
Payload adds another consideration, particularly as organisations evaluate electric HGVs. If an organisation is carrying large but relatively lightweight products, available space may be the primary constraint. If it is carrying bricks, mortar, or other dense materials, payload becomes much more important. The objective should be to understand the characteristics of the order, vehicle and route together rather than treating them as separate planning decisions.
Identify capacity problems early
Third-party logistics providers (3PL) are, and have always been, a required part of logistics infrastructure, but problems arise when businesses have to rely on them at short notice because their own capacity requirements weren’t understood soon enough.
Consider an organisation that uses batch planning and creates the following day’s routes at a fixed cut-off point. It may only be discovered at that stage that its fleet doesn’t have enough capacity to complete every order already accepted. At that point, using a 3PL can become an unavoidable variable cost.
Having better capacity, visibility and real-time optimisation tools can change that. Operators can restrict delivery slots when capacity is constrained, allocate orders differently or plan external capacity in advance rather than reacting once the problem has already occurred. This is also why “growth” doesn’t automatically mean adding more vehicles.
A company with 100 vehicles growing by 20% year-on-year may assume that it therefore needs 120 vehicles, which isn’t necessarily accurate. Whether the organization requires new vehicle assets depends on the profile of its customers, orders and deliveries, alongside how effectively its existing fleet is being used.
The scale of the utilisation challenge is significant. Department for Transport figures show that GB-registered HGVs travelled almost 5.9 billion kilometres empty in 2025, representing 31% of their total domestic vehicle kilometres. While some empty running is unavoidable, the figures reinforce why existing fleet utilisation should be understood before additional capacity is added.
Conclusion
For operators looking to reduce distribution costs and emissions while improving customer satisfaction, the first step should be to audit how the current operation is planned. Logistics operators need to understand which decisions happen automatically and which still depend on manual intervention. Then they should assess whether planning considers distance, time, cost, capacity and delivery windows together and whether each delivery makes commercial sense and meets customer expectations.




